How does the possibility of a future inheritance affect a property settlement?

Written on the 19 September 2013 by Matthew Carney

There is no absolute rule; it will depend on the circumstances.

The issue has been the subject of a number of applications for property settlement over the years and below I set out how the Courts have dealt with such applications.

The most well known case is Tulloch v White. In this case, the husband argued that his former wife had an expectation of inheritance from her mother's estate. The wife's mother was aged 81, a widower, in reasonable health and had two surviving adult children, one being the wife.

The husband essentially argued that the mother's Will left a half share of her estate to the wife, therefore creating the expectation.

The husband's argument was rejected by the Court. In so rejecting it, the Court stated:

"We do not consider there is any absolute rule. The ultimate criterion is whether the evidence is, or may be, relevant to the just and equitable process. An expectancy of inheritance will not be relevant in many proceedings. In the end, relevance must depend upon the nature of the claims being put forward and the facts of the particular case... there must be a worthwhile connection between a specific element of the party's case and the suggested expectancyIt is ultimately a question of fact and degree. During the course of argument a number of obvious examples at each end of the spectrum were referred to. In a case where the testator had already made a will favourable to the party but no longer had testamentary capacity and there was evidence of his or her likely impending death in circumstances where there may be a significant estate, and where there was a connection to s 75(2) factors, it would be shutting one's eyes to realities to treat that as irrelevant. On the other hand, the bald assertion that one of the parties has an elderly relative who has property and is or is likely to benefit that party is so speculative that it would be inappropriate to contemplate it as relevant in a s 79 determination, it being too remote to affect the justice and equity of the case in any worthwhile way."

Essentially, the Court took the view that there was no obligation on the wife's mother to choose to benefit the wife or any other person or institution and furthermore, even if there was, any such benefit may be eroded over time by intervening events, such as expensive medical care and treatment, donations to third parties or institutions or other economic uncertainties.

However, the Court also stated that "we do not consider there is any absolute rule" and there may well be circumstances when the Court will make an adjustment due to an expected inheritance.

Such circumstances arose in the case of De Angelis & De Angelis. In this case, again there was an application by the husband in relation to the wife's expected inheritance from the wife's mother's estate. However, in this case, there was evidence that the husband had undertaken a considerable amount of work on properties owned by the wife's mother, at no cost. The Court stated:

"we think it important to remember that the Court is requiredto accord justice and equity to both parties. The question therefore has to be asked whether, in the present case, it would be just and equitable to the husband for the Court to have ignored the probability that, in what could well be [a] very short period of time (given the ages of her aunt and mother), the wife could well be the owner of two properties having a combined value of almost the same amount as the value of the parties' property currently available for distribution, and particularly in circumstances where the husband had been found to have done substantial improvement and maintenance work on both properties? ... We consider that it would have been unjust to the husband to ignore this matter even if it was categorised only as a possibility and not a probability".

De Angelis can be contrasted against the case Tulloch as a consequence of the significant works that the husband undertook to the properties. The husband through his contributions had significantly improved the value of the properties which the wife would likely benefit from.

While the general rule is that the Court will not take into consideration the expectation of an inheritance there are exceptions. In such situations, the Court also has the power to adjourn proceedings if there is likely to be a significant change in the financial circumstances of the parties to the marriage or either of them.


If you have any questions about this topic you should contact Matthew Carney on 1800 994 279 or email him. A member of our Family Law Team will endeavour to respond to your enquiry within 24 hours.

- Matthew Carney
   Family Lawyer

Matthew Carney - Family Lawyer

Family Lawers in NSW


Author: Matthew Carney
About: Matthew Carney is a Lawyer who is a member of both the Family & De Facto Law Team and our Criminal Law Team. Matthew provides practical and effective family law advice to clients in all matters including property settlements, parenting matters, applications for divorce, annulment applications, child support, contravention, recovery and relocation proceedings. Matthew assists his clients to resolve matters in their best interests at the earliest possible opportunity. Matthew explains the law in an individual way tailored to each clients needs while demonstrating genuine care and compassion in this difficult time.
Connect via: Twitter Google+ LinkedIn

Contact Us Now

We respond in 24 hours or less

Please provide details regarding your matter so we can assist you

Enquiry Form

Fill out our enquiry form and we'll respond within 24 hours

Listen to the captcha
 
Publications

What happens to superannuation after a couple separates?

Under the Family Law Act superannuation splitting laws enable couples to split their superannuation interests (transfer superannuation from one spouses fund to the other spouse's fund) in family law property settlements following a relationship breakdown. A superannuation agreement is usually included part of an overall property settl...

Read More ...

Pokémon Go, but don't go too far and trespass on private land

There have been reported incidents of people getting seriously injured while playing Pokémon Go simply because they were not watching where they going. There have also been reported incidents of armed criminals using the game's location-based features to lure unsuspecting victims into secluded areas (e.g. an empty carpark at nigh...

Read More ...

How do you find a loved one's will?

How Do You Find A Loved One's Will from Turnbull Hill Lawyers When a loved one has passed away it can be difficult to know what their intentions were when it comes to their estate. Sometimes loved ones will give specific instructions as to where their last will is kept, however, unfortunately in most cases death ca...

Read More ...

The power of a handwritten note or video recording when drafting a Will

Families and lives can be complex and for various reasons, both good and bad, a person may not wish to leave their Estate, or a portion of their Estate, to someone who may be entitled to it under the Family Provision Act (which deals with contested Wills). It may be that you do not get along with a child who you have been estranged from f...

Read More ...

Cyber harassment, cyber stalking and cyber bullying: the offences and penalties

Note: If an individual is exposed to cyber bullying, cyber stalking and/or cyber harassment the matter should be reported to NSW Police. The Laws Cyber bullying, cyber stalking and cyber harassment has increased in focus due to technological advancements and the ease of anonymity on the internet. Since 2015 all NSW police offices h...

Read More ...

| 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 | Next


Events
All you need to know about Wills, Powers of Attorney and Enduring Guardians...

Wednesday 10th Aug 2016
Time 6:00pm - 7:30pm 10th Aug


Blogs
"Many thanks Kirstin (Fulcher). Again a huge tha...

Laura

Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation

enquiries@turnbullhill.com.au